Follow us twitter facebook
Edition: Global
Click here to subscribe toour free weekly newsletter click here
Laws and regulations

Parabens and children: no health risk according to the SCCS

Cosmetics containing parabens and intended for children under three years of age do not pose any health risks according to the Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS), who however draws attention on the products used in the nappy area of children under 6 months.


The Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS), who is in charge of advising the European Commission on scientific matters, further addressed the issue on the safety of parabens in cosmetic products, focusing this time on the specific case of products intended for young children.

Children under three years

In a previous opinion [1], the Committee had indeed confirmed the safety of the two commonly used parabens (methyl paraben and ethyl paraben) within the limits of recommended concentrations (0.4%) and lowered to 0.19% the concentration use of butylparaben and propylparaben. If this decision had the effect of rather reassuring the industry, whose practices were already consistent with the Committee’s recommendations, the latter was criticized for not specifically addressing the case of children under three, considered more sensitive to risks linked to hormonal disruptors.

Soon after, the Danish authorities invoked the safeguard clause, arguing that butylparaben and propylparaben were to be banned in cosmetics for children under three years, a ban in force in the country since March 15. The activation of the safeguard clause by a Member State of the European Union automatically resulting in the referral of the Commission, the latter asked the CSSC to clarify its opinion in the light of the objections raised by Denmark.

Clarifications from the CSSC

In its opinion of 10 October (CSSC/1446/11), the Committee therefore recalls that its previous risk analysis of parabens was based on particularly conservative assumptions including concerning the actual exposure to parabens, and that the data now available seems to confirm that the reality of the exposure in Europe and in the United States is actually far less than the one imagined at the time. Given the safety margins adopted, the SCCS believes that parabens are not a safety issue, and this regardless of the age of users.

However the Committee noted, that in the case of leave-on products intended for application in the nappy area of children under 6 months, a risk could not be excluded, because of the risk of skin lesions in this area and because of the immaturity of the immune system at this age. However, such concerns should only arise, the Committee said, in the case the worst level of exposure is retained. Unfortunately, the Committee indicated that the currently available scientific data did permit the Committee to further refine its position on the subject.

Details provided by the SCCS strongly weaken the position of the Danish authorities, but do not provide answers to all questions. So it is now up to the Commission to decide.

Vincent Gallon

Footnotes

[1] Opinion SCCS/1348/10 of March 22, 2011

© 2011 - Premium Beauty News - www.premiumbeautynews.com
latest news
Focus
spip-vignette

A new trade show dedicated to clean beauty in London

Dubbed Clean Beauty in London the new trade show intends to gather experts, scientists, suppliers, brands, influencers and journalists under one roof “to build the future of clean beauty.” Taking place on October 12 & 13, 2020 at The Brewery, located at 52 Chiswell Street at the heart of London, the event aims to encourage (...)

read more
job opportunities
Experts’ views
India emerges as the next beauty giant

Asia Cosme Lab
India emerges as the next beauty giant

Thanks to a growing young population (first youth population in the world) and the emergence of a vast middle class, as well as a higher Internet connection from both urban and rural areas, India is set to emerge as the next beauty giant after China. Asia Cosme Lab took a deep dive in the fascinating Indian market, where both (...)

read more
Webinars
E-shop - latest publications
Regulations on the registration of cosmetic products in China (part2)
95.00 € excl. tax
MARKET REPORT : Black & Multi-Hued Beauty Trends
4000.00 € excl. tax
Regulations on the registration of cosmetic products in China (part1)
135.00 € excl. tax
Go to top ↑

Features

We use cookies to give you a better browsing experience. By continuing your visit to this site, you accept the use of cookies. Read more and set cookies
close