Follow us twitter facebook
Edition: Global
Click here to subscribe toour free weekly newsletter click here
Laws and regulations

Alternative methods to animal tests not fully available by 2013

Despite substantial progress over the past years, experts say that alternative methods to fully replace animal tests in the European Union will not be available by 2013. However, significant contributions to reduce, refine and partially replace animal testing have been made and are feasible before full substitution is possible.

Scientific report

In 2010, the European commission appointed a panel of scientific experts to report on the current status and future prospects of alternative methods to animal testing for cosmetics, and to provide realistic estimates of the time required for the development of alternative methods where not already existing.

This work was coordinated by theEuropean Centre for the Validation of Alternative Methods (ECVAM) and underwent a period of public consultation prior to its finalisation and publication in the peer-reviewed journal Archives of Toxicology.

According to the experts, considerable scientific challenges still have to be overcome before a full replacement of animal tests will be possible. Whereas substantial progress has been made over the past years, they predict that for toxicokinetics, repeated dose toxicity, carcinogenicity, skin sensitisation, and reproductive toxicity, alternative methods to fully replace animal tests will not be available by 2013.

More particularly:

  • No specific timeline could be estimated in the areas of toxicokinetics, repeated dose toxicity, carcinogenicity and reproductive toxicity due to the underlying scientific challenges.
  • The timelines estimated for full replacement of animal tests in the area of skin sensitisation point to a further 7-9 years (i.e. 2017-2019).

Parliament and Council decision

This study [1] will be an important input for the Commission’s report to the Parliament and the Council expected in mid-2011, regarding the technical difficulties in complying with the ban on animal testing. Indeed, the European Commission must review the situation regarding the technical difficulties in extending the ban to the most complex tests, including skin sensitisation and carcinogenicity, reproductive toxicity and toxicokinetics, for which the deadline was set to March 2013.

While full replacement is not yet accomplished or possible by 2013, the EU experts argue that there is a potential for partial replacement strategies. In the short to mid-term, providing a combined “toolbox” of well-defined test methods with established reliability and relevance for particular purposes, could support the development of integrated testing strategies. “While each of the methods alone may not be able to generate all required information, their combination might provide a sufficient basis for an integrated safety assessment withthe ultimate aim of completely replacing animal testing.

Anti-testing group disappointed

Animal testing opposition group, the BUAV, expressed extreme disappointment over the content of the final report by EU experts. The group said that delaying the ban will not speed up the development and acceptance of non-animal alternatives. “Rather, the pressure of a deadline has helped to speed up the development of new alternatives - thereby saving the lives of thousands of animals worldwide.

Vincent Gallon


[1] Alternative (non-animal) methods for cosmetics testing: current status and future prospects, 2010

© 2011 - Premium Beauty News -
latest news

Luxe Pack and MakeUp in Los Angeles: A proven powerful partnership

2018 proved to be a momentous year for MakeUp in and Luxe Pack! It marked the beginning of a powerful West Coast partnership that brought both btob platforms to one venue. MakeUp in…the leading stage for beauty and make-up products, trends and formulation and Luxe Pack, the premier tradeshow dedicated to luxury packaging for all (...)

read more
job opportunities
Experts’ views
Giving skin the protection it needs against the pollution

Lipotec - Lubrizol
Giving skin the protection it needs against the pollution

The health of the planet and our own are in danger due, among other things, to the big problem of pollution. Despite the increasing awareness of its significance and the efforts made to combat it, in the last decades there has been an unprecedented worsening as a result of human activity. Contamination affects nearly every corner of (...)

read more


We use cookies to give you a better browsing experience. By continuing your visit to this site, you accept the use of cookies. Read more and set cookies